What an exchange cage looks like
You have seen these even if you never used one. A locked metal cage, often at the front of a grocery store, big-box store, or gas station, holds a stack of 20‑lb grill cylinders. You leave your empty (or partly empty) tank and take a full one. Brands such as Blue Rhino run this model; their official finder is explicitly a propane tank exchange locator, not a refill map.
Exchange is fast, and you usually get a tank that has been inspected and is not past its requalification date. You also typically pay a flat price for a “full” 20‑lb tank — and you do not get credit for propane you left in the one you turned in. Most cages only handle the standard 20‑lb grill cylinder. Horizontal tanks, 30‑lb and 40‑lb cylinders, 100‑lb tanks, and many RV cylinders will not fit this system.
What a refill station looks like
A refill station has a bulk tank — often a large white tank in the lot — and a trained attendant, or a pay-at-the-pump dispenser, that meters propane by the gallon into the cylinder you already own. U-Haul, many Tractor Supply stores, some Ace Hardware stores, truck stops, and local propane dealers work this way. Official U-Haul location pages describe refill as cheaper than exchange because you pay only for the propane that goes into your tank.
Refill stations are the places to try if you have a 30‑lb, 40‑lb, or 100‑lb cylinder, a horizontal tank, a forklift cylinder, or an RV. That does not mean every refill station takes every tank. Tractor Supply’s company refill page, for example, says it can fill tanks up to 100 lb and mounted RV tanks that pass inspection, but it does not fill 1‑lb camp-stove cylinders or RV autogas (the fuel that runs some RV engines).
A practical tell: if you see only a cage of identical 20‑lb tanks and no bulk tank or fill hose, you are looking at an exchange. If someone will connect a hose to your valve and charge you by the gallon, you are at a refill.
Why the difference shows up in search
Search “propane near me” and you will often get both. An exchange cage is a propane business. So is a pay-at-the-pump fill station. So is a dealer that only delivers to home tanks. The listing rarely says which one you found. Hours can also lie: a store may be open when no certified attendant is on duty, and some Tractor Supply stores do not even surface in a generic “propane dealer” search.
What to check before you drive
- Is it a refill, an exchange, or both?
- Will they fill your exact tank size and orientation (including horizontal and RV tanks)?
- Are the cylinder’s manufacture or requalification dates still valid, and is the tank free of damage?
- Are refill hours the same as store hours? Call if it matters.
- Can an RV or truck actually reach the dispenser, or is the tank behind a fence or a short hose?
Legal fills leave some vapor space — a “full” tank is not usually filled to the brim. Out-of-date or damaged tanks are commonly refused.
Where to go next
The first city page is Austin, Texas, with U-Haul, Tractor Supply, Ace, and a local dealer, each tied to an official page we opened. If you are buying a new tank or accessories later, any partner links will be marked on the affiliate disclosure page. None are live yet.